Since 2016, Kelsey has taught the following undergraduate courses at Boston College:

1. First Year Writing Seminar: Writing & Pop Culture (syllabus)
2. Literature Core: Literature & Adaptation (syllabus)
3. Shakespeare: Text, Performance, Adaptation (syllabus)
4. Literature Core: Queer Drama and Film
5. Women in American Literature
6. Women in Hollywood (co-taught with Christina Klein)

In 2019, Kelsey was selected as a Woods College Dean’s Summer Session Teaching Fellow. In 2018, she received the Donald J. White Award for Excellence in Graduate Student Teaching.